Almost a million young people in Britain are neither working nor studying, and a major review commissioned by the government says only a wholesale overhaul of the system meant to help them can turn the numbers around.
Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, published his review in full on Tuesday. It calls for a complete reset of the system and warns that without it Britain risks a lost generation. About 13 per cent of people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training, the highest share since 2014, with 981,000 young people in that position in the second quarter of this year.
The review sets a ten-year ambition to cut the rate to around 5 per cent by 2036, with 440,000 more young people in work and about 600,000 more in education, employment or training each year by then. Milburn describes the moment as a fork in the road: carry on with arrangements that have failed for a quarter of a century, or adopt a plan to end long-term youth unemployment. “A lost generation is not a fact of life. It’s a choice,” he said at the report’s launch.
At the centre of the plan is a new Youth Opportunity Service in England, giving every young person a legal right to support. Each person would be paired with a named adviser and offered a personal plan leading to an apprenticeship, a college place, supported employment or a job within four months. The service would bring employment, careers, health and practical help together in one place, answering to regional mayors and local leaders, and would be in place across all of England by 2029.
The review also reaches back to the start of life. It proposes that 90 per cent of children arrive at school ready to learn, with basic life skills, by the age of five. The current figure in England is 68 per cent, against a government target of 75 per cent by 2028. Young people would get immediate access to mental health support without needing a diagnosis first, and the number completing apprenticeships would double.
Employers would be given new reasons to take on young staff. The review proposes gradually lowering the National Insurance employers pay for young adult workers. Two existing schemes would stay: the Youth Jobs Grant, paying employers £3,000 for hiring a young person out of work for six months, and the Jobs Guarantee, under which the government underwrites a paid six-month job. Young adults will soon qualify for the guarantee after 12 months on Universal Credit, rather than 18.
Paying for the reforms would mean a sharp break in how benefits treat the under-25s. Young adults would lose the health top-up of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment. In their place would come a Youth Allowance at the current base rate of Universal Credit, and a new Additional Cost Allowance. Those who can never work would be supported through a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance. The review argues the balance of spending is badly out of line: in 2024-25, for every £1 spent helping young people into work or education, £25 went on youth benefits. By 2036, Milburn wants that ratio brought to £2 on benefits for every £1 on work support.
The proposals have drawn a mixed response. The Conservatives said they would back the parts Milburn gets right, but the shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, called the plan in places too cautious and too reliant on the expensive hand of the state. Reform UK said a ten-year wait would consign another generation to the scrap heap, while the Greens called the proposals extremely concerning. Labour backbenchers from the left of the party have also raised concerns, warning that benefit cuts risk pushing young people further away. The work and pensions secretary, Pat McFadden, sought to reassure them, describing the plan as a new settlement that brings together the help young people need in one place. Prime Minister Andy Burnham has promised to intervene from early childhood and said benefit changes would come only with a root-and-branch rethink of youth support.
Sources: BBC News, “Complete system reset needed to get 440,000 young people into work, says major review” (https://worldrightnowlive.com/story/complete-system-reset-needed-to-get-440-000-young-people-into-work-say); The Guardian, “Alan Milburn urges Burnham to spend billions on ‘new deal’ for young people” (https://worldrightnowlive.com/story/burnham-pledges-early-intervention-and-benefits-backstop-to-tackle-you)
