Senate Confirms St. John to Fifth Circuit as Republicans Race to Fill Trump’s Judicial Vacancies

The United States Capitol building in Washington, DC. Photo: Noclip / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

The United States Senate confirmed Judge Anna St. John to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday, handing President Donald Trump another conservative appointment to one of the country’s most influential appellate benches.

The Republican-led chamber voted 52-46 to elevate St. John, a district judge in Louisiana, to the New Orleans-based court, which is known for regularly ruling in favour of conservative litigants. The vote came as Senate Republicans race to confirm as many of Mr Trump’s 21 remaining judicial nominees as possible before Democrats take control of the chamber on 3 January.

Republicans also moved four district court nominees onto the floor for consideration during the lame-duck session, and the Senate Judiciary Committee advanced three more on Tuesday: Robert Long for the Middle District of Florida, Peter Mansfield for the Eastern District of Louisiana and Jesus Osete for the Western District of Missouri.

“The federal judiciary can’t function without judges filling these critical vacancies, and I’m not going to let the federal bench stagnate for the next several years while Democrats block judicial nominations,” said Senator Chuck Grassley, the committee’s Republican chairman, at Tuesday’s hearing.

The confirmation drive hit a snag in Oklahoma, however, where the committee put off votes on two district court nominees, Zach West and Trevor Pemberton. Outgoing Republican Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina said he would not vote to advance West because of opposition from one of Oklahoma’s senators, Alan Armstrong, whose term ends at the end of this month.

A person familiar with the matter said the delay reflected a White House preference that both nominees move together, creating pressure to resolve the logjam. The path forward may open on 30 November, when Armstrong is succeeded by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, whose spokesperson said he supports moving both nominees forward. Tillis said on Tuesday that if that is what Mr Hern wants, he would drop his opposition. “I think he’ll get done,” he said. “But they’re running it down to the wire.”

St. John has spent only a short time on the federal bench. The Senate confirmed her in March, by 51 votes to 45, to her district court seat after a career as a conservative legal activist. Since 2015 she had worked at the Center for Class Action Fairness, now part of the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, campaigning against class action settlements it says benefit lawyers while delivering little to consumers.

Democrats opposed her swift elevation to the 17-member appeals court, which already has 11 other judges appointed by Republican presidents. They also criticised her testimony in 2021 defending arbitration as Congress considered legislation to end forced arbitration in cases of workplace sexual assault and harassment.

Two other Trump judicial nominees have run into resistance from Republican senators in their home states since the 3 November election, forcing the White House to withdraw and replace one of them to avoid leaving a vacancy open.

Sources: Reuters — “US Senate confirms Trump appellate judge pick as Oklahoma nominees stall” (https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-senate-confirms-trump-appellate-judge-pick-oklahoma-nominees-stall-2026-11-17/)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *