A federal appeals court has ruled that the US government wrongly withheld nearly $74 million in highway funding from New York state in a dispute over commercial driving licences held by immigrants. A three-judge panel of the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan said on Friday that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration acted in a way that was “arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law” when it penalised the state.
The dispute began after an audit found that nearly 33,000 commercial driving licences in New York remained valid even though the holders’ immigration status had changed or their work permits had expired. The Transportation Department demanded the state revoke the licences and, when it refused, withheld the highway money. New York sued in April, with Attorney General Letitia James arguing the state was being unfairly deprived of money needed to repair roads and bridges. Governor Kathy Hochul called the cuts “devastating” and described them as “political payback”.
The court said New York could not be blamed for failing to cancel a licence when a driver lost the legal right to remain in the United States, because the rules requiring cancellation were not in place at the time. The licences cover commercial vehicles including lorries, trailers, limousines and buses.
The case follows a tightening of the rules governing when immigrants can obtain a commercial driving licence under Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. Concerns about driver qualifications intensified after a crash in Florida in August 2025, in which a lorry driver accused of making an illegal U-turn killed three people. Duffy said the driver, who is from India, should never have been licensed. Audits in every state found non-domiciled commercial licences that stayed valid long after work permits expired, or were issued without properly verifying citizenship status. Since then, about 26,000 drivers have been taken off the road for failing to demonstrate English proficiency, and the department said 30,000 commercial licences were cancelled because they had been issued illegally. Immigrants make up about 20% of all lorry drivers in the United States, while non-domiciled licences account for about 5% of all commercial licences, or roughly 200,000 drivers.
The Transportation Department said on Friday that it made no sense for states to let trucking licences for foreign drivers run years beyond their legal stay in the United States. “We’ve put a stop to the madness to keep the driving public safe,” it said in a statement. Hochul and James welcomed the ruling in a joint statement, calling it “a win for the millions of New Yorkers who rely on safe roads to travel” and for “drivers who power our state’s economy”. Immigrant groups have said they believe many drivers are being unfairly targeted. It was not immediately clear whether the department would appeal.
Sources: Associated Press — “Court Says US Wrongly Withheld NY’s Highway Funds Over Immigrant Licenses” (https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/east/2026/11/16/892654.htm).
