Indonesia’s digital ministry has asked Google to provide a thorough justification for removing more than 19,000 YouTube channels supportive of the Indonesian government, saying the move risked being misinterpreted. The request came on Friday after ministry officials met representatives of Google Indonesia.
The channels were removed between July and September and disclosed in Google’s 2026 third-quarter influence operations bulletin, published on 30 October. Google said the channels were “supportive of the Indonesian government and its administration” and had been terminated as part of its investigation into coordinated influence operations. Indonesia topped the list of countries with the largest number of removed channels, followed by China and Russia.
The ministry asked Google to explain its methodology, the review process, how it measures accuracy and what its detection error rates are, and how it determined where the content creators or operators behind the accounts were based. “We asked Google to provide a written explanatory note, along with examples, detailing the parameters and methods used to detect and take action against accounts that were ultimately terminated,” senior ministry official Mediodecci Lustarini said.
Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the criteria it used, the spike in removals in the third quarter, or the Indonesian government’s request for clarification.
The removals come as President Prabowo Subianto’s approval ratings have fallen, with dissatisfaction mounting over the state of the economy and his flagship social programmes. His rating fell to 51% in July — one of the months covered by Google’s bulletin — from about 80% in November last year. Google did not mention any of the Indonesian political context or elaborate on why it determined the accounts were part of coordinated influence operations.
This report is single-sourced to Reuters: Google has not responded to the request for comment, so its criteria for the removals remain unverified.
Sources: Reuters — “Indonesia asks Google to clarify removal of 19,000 YouTube channels, ministry says”, https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/indonesia-asks-google-clarify-removal-19000-youtube-channels-ministry-says-2026-11-20/
