Democratic Senator Tammy Baldwin has introduced legislation to revoke China’s permanent normal trade relations with the United States, days before President Donald Trump is due to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping for a third time this year.
The bill, introduced on Tuesday, would end the permanent normal trade relations status that has governed US–China trade since 2002, one year after the legislation is enacted. Chinese imports would shift to the higher regular tariff rates set out in the US Harmonised Tariff Schedule.
Existing “most favoured nation” tariff rates for China average about 2.5 per cent. Trump has already heaped punitive duties on Chinese goods — about 25 per cent during his first term and up to 20 per cent more during his second, under the trade truce now in force between the two countries.
Baldwin, who voted against granting China the status in 2000 while serving in the House of Representatives, said the United States needed to reset the relationship. “We need to reset our trade relationship with China, be honest that they have undercut us at every turn, and put the focus back where it matters — prioritising American workers, manufacturers and families,” she said in a statement.
Her office said there was “growing recognition that granting China PNTR failed to deliver the changes in China’s economic and trade practices that were promised”, and that the bill would establish a more durable American trade policy. The US–China Economic and Security Review Commission, an independent bipartisan legislative agency, also recommended revoking the status in November 2024.
The bill would also direct the US Trade Representative’s office, together with the Commerce Department, the US International Trade Commission and other bodies, to report on the trade and economic challenges posed by China.
Previous attempts to end China’s special treatment have repeatedly failed, held up by competing economic priorities, legislative bottlenecks and shifting trade dynamics, with Republicans not challenging Trump’s tariff pressure. But anti-China sentiment is growing in Congress, particularly among Democrats who won control of both the Senate and the House of Representatives in elections this month.
The timing puts the bill squarely in the middle of the week’s diplomacy. Trump, who ordered a review of China’s trade status when he took office in January 2025, meets Xi in Shenzhen to discuss a fragile trade-war truce that is due to expire in January. Beijing has accused Washington of “economic coercion” over its latest restrictions on Chinese access to advanced chips.
The costs of revocation are disputed. A US International Trade Commission report released in August estimated that ending the status would raise US consumer prices by 0.7 per cent in the long run and reduce economic output by 0.2 per cent, with trade-weighted average tariffs rising by 35.2 percentage points. Two of the commission’s members — one Republican and one Democrat — challenged that conclusion, arguing the analysis failed to account for the economic harm caused by granting the status in the first place.
Even if the bill passes, Trump could still veto it.
Sources: Reuters — “US Democratic senator introduces bill to end China’s trade status ahead of Trump-Xi meeting” (https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-democratic-senator-introduces-bill-end-chinas-trade-status-ahead-trump-xi-2026-11-17/)
